
Today when debating about online encyclopedias the first thing that comes to one’s mind is Wikipedia, a free on line encyclopedia containing millions of articles that have been collaborated by viewers worldwide and where almost of its articles can be edited by anyone who can access it. The main issue with Wikipedia is accountability since its articles are not credited, that has led teachers to prohibit students to use it as a reference source. Many Wikipedia defenders argue that the site is a good source for students to start their researches and its access should not be denied in school libraries.
Goggle competing with Wikipedia, recently launched “Knol Project” (Google calls it Knol: a unit of knowledge) where authors’ names are included in the articles, emphasizing authorship thus, addressing the main shortcoming of Wikipedia, accountability. I first learned about “Knol” last fall but didn’t access it until now. So, in order to do a few projects for school I decided to give “Knol” a chance. I am happy with Knol so far, it’s easy to search and the fact that all the results you get has authorship it gives me peace of mind and then it’s up to me to access an article and eventually use it on my research; but still I’m an early user. There are several criticisms to Knol, some say it is a vehicle for self-promotion, others say that articles are incomplete and inaccurate. I think it’s up to the user to decide. Here is Knol’s link, you decide:
http://knol.google.com/k